Prosecutors intend to take a look at Karen Reade once more. What occurs subsequent?

The homicide trial of Mansfield lady Karen Reed, accused of killing her Boston police officer boyfriend, led to a mistrial Monday after 5 days of deliberations. However, Norfolk County prosecutors say they intend to take a look at Reed once more.

A spokesperson for the District Legal professional’s Place of work mentioned Monday afternoon that Pass judgement on Beverly Cannon is anticipated to set a brand new listening to date in an instant following a standing convention scheduled for Monday, July 22 at 2 p.m.

If a retrial is ordered, it should start inside 12 months of that date, Norfolk District Legal professional spokesman David Traub mentioned, mentioning Rule 36d of the Massachusetts Laws of Prison Process. Traub additionally identified that during a brand new trial, “new or other proof may not be utterly excluded.”

Former Suffolk District Legal professional Dan Conley, now a spouse at Mintz, mentioned he thinks it will no longer be “irrelevant” for Norfolk District Legal professional Michael Morrissey’s workplace to re-prosecute Reed.

• Learn extra: JPass judgement on announces mistrial in Karen Reed homicide case

Conley mentioned one of the most primary components influencing his choice to take action could be a break up jury, including that he anticipated jurors within the case to talk publicly about their causes for believing Reed used to be in charge or blameless.

The jurors weren’t referred to as of Monday night time, and a clerk on the Dedham courthouse the place Reed is being attempted mentioned a listing of jurors would no longer be made to be had for the reason that case led to a mistrial.

However, Conley mentioned there may be additionally a possibility prosecutors may trade their minds — specifically with reference to the costs in opposition to Reed, who used to be charged with second-degree homicide, manslaughter whilst riding beneath the affect and fleeing the scene of a crash inflicting damage or loss of life.

“Numerous that may most likely pop out over the following couple of months,” Conley mentioned in an interview Monday night time.

Maureen Boyle, a Stonehill Faculty professor and veteran crime reporter, mentioned she believed Reed used to be overcharged.

“The info don’t enhance the second-degree homicide price leveled in opposition to Reed,” Boyle mentioned.

Sooner than a standing convention later this month, it is as much as the District Legal professional’s Place of work to decide in the event that they nonetheless have a “excellent religion trust” that the proof can persuade a jury that Reed killed O’Keefe.

Daniel Medved, a legislation professor at Northeastern College, mentioned mistrials are “reasonably uncommon” and it’s herbal for prosecutors to get to the bottom of to take a look at a defendant once more, particularly once they really feel justice wasn’t finished.

“As soon as one of the most feelings subside and time has handed, the important thing factor is they have got to seem within the reflect and say, ‘Howdy, used to be this a smart use of our assets? What would we have now finished in a different way to make sure a conviction? Can we in truth assume the end result may well be other subsequent time?'” Medved mentioned.

Medved mentioned prosecutors may proceed investigating the case and search new proof along with engaging in a “thorough assessment” of proof offered at trial.

“I believe we will have to take their response lately with a bit warning as a result of it is a herbal response after an match like this. However we’re going to have to peer through the years if they will sing the similar song,” Medved mentioned.

As for the precise timing of Reed’s new trial, Conley mentioned a number of components will affect when it starts, together with whether or not Pass judgement on Beverly Cannon pushes for an expedited retrial and whether or not Reed’s protection legal professionals ask for an extension of time.

“The commonwealth has a duty to transport temporarily,” Medved mentioned. “However continuously it is the protection that claims we will have to transfer a bit slower right here.”

• Learn extra: Learn what jurors wrote that resulted in a wrongful conviction within the Karen Reed homicide case

Cannon declared a mistrial for the 3rd time after jurors despatched him a notice informing him they have been deadlocked. Every of the former two occasions, he despatched them again to planned, even though the second one time he did so after studying an instruction referred to as the Tui-Rodriguez instruction, which is continuously observed as a final hotel when jurors are caught, in line with Medved.

Of their ultimate notes Monday, jurors mentioned some felt prosecutors had met their legal responsibility to turn out Reed’s guilt past an affordable doubt, whilst others believed that they had no longer. Cannon informed jurors they have been brushed aside from their carrier, which incorporated 29 days of testimony and 5 days of deliberations.

Norfolk County prosecutors charged Reed, 44, with second-degree homicide within the loss of life of John O’Keefe, who used to be discovered chilly to touch and subconscious out of doors a house in Canton on Jan. 29, 2022.

Reed has pleaded no longer in charge to second-degree homicide, motor car murder whilst working a car whilst intoxicated, and fleeing the scene after a motor car coincidence inflicting loss of life.